Skip to content

Website audit checklist for small businesses: 30 checks that bring in more enquiries

A website audit isn't about chasing a perfect score. It's about finding the handful of problems that quietly turn visitors away. Work through these thirty checks — or run our free audit, which tests most of them automatically in about twenty seconds.

Updated · Aethel Digital

1. Can a visitor who wants to hire you actually do it?

  • A clear call to action on the first screen of your homepage — on a phone, without scrolling.
  • A contact form that asks only what you need (name, email, a message). Every extra field costs enquiries.
  • Your phone number as text, tappable on mobile (a tel: link), not an image.
  • Your email address visible, or a form that works and confirms it was sent.
  • Proof: reviews, testimonials, logos of clients, credentials, photos of real work.
  • An instant option for people ready now: online booking, live chat or WhatsApp.

2. Can search engines find and present you?

  • A unique, descriptive title on every page, 50–60 characters, with what you do and where.
  • A meta description of 120–160 characters that reads like an ad.
  • One H1 per page that says what the page is about.
  • Not blocked: no noindex tag on pages you want found, and robots.txt not blocking the site.
  • An XML sitemap listed in robots.txt and submitted in Google Search Console.
  • A canonical URL on each page so www/non-www and tracking parameters don't split your ranking.
  • Structured data (schema.org LocalBusiness or Organization) with your name, address, phone and hours.
  • A complete, verified Google Business Profile that matches the details on your site.

3. Is it fast?

Google's Core Web Vitals are the standard. Aim for the "good" thresholds measured on a mobile phone:

MetricWhat it measuresGood
LCP — Largest Contentful PaintWhen the main content appears2.5 s or less
INP — Interaction to Next PaintHow quickly the page responds to taps200 ms or less
CLS — Cumulative Layout ShiftHow much things jump while loading0.1 or less
  • Server response under 600 ms.
  • Images in WebP or AVIF, sized for the screen, lazy-loaded below the fold, with width and height set.
  • Few third-party scripts — every chat widget, tracker and font service costs load time.
  • Compression (Brotli or gzip) and sensible caching.

4. Does it work on a phone?

More than half of small business site visits come from phones. Open your site on one and check:

  • Nothing scrolls sideways.
  • Buttons and links are at least 24×24 pixels with space between them (WCAG 2.2) — 44px is better.
  • Body text is at least 16px; nothing important is under 12px.
  • Text contrast meets 4.5:1 against its background.
  • Zoom isn't disabled in the viewport settings.
  • Forms use the right keyboards (email, phone, number) and have visible labels.

5. Is it secure and trustworthy?

  • HTTPS everywhere, with HSTS so browsers never fall back to plain HTTP.
  • No mixed content (images or scripts loaded over http:// on a secure page).
  • Security headers: Content-Security-Policy, X-Content-Type-Options, frame protection, Referrer-Policy.
  • Plugins, themes and libraries up to date — outdated WordPress plugins and old jQuery versions are the most common way small business sites get hacked.
  • SPF and DMARC records on your domain, so nobody can send convincing emails pretending to be you.
  • A privacy policy, and a cookie banner that gives a real choice if you serve visitors in the EU or UK.

6. Is there a reason to come back?

Most visitors won't buy on the first visit. Give them a way to stay in touch — a newsletter, useful guides, social profiles — and a site structure that makes the next page obvious. Fresh, genuinely helpful content is also what lets you rank for the hundreds of specific questions your customers search.

Fix the high-impact items first: anything that stops people contacting you, anything that stops Google indexing you, and anything that makes the site slow or broken on a phone.

Questions

How often should I audit my website?

A quick check every quarter and a full audit once a year, or after any redesign, platform change or big drop in enquiries.

Is a free audit tool enough?

Automated tools are good at measurable problems — speed, tags, headers, mobile layout. They can't judge whether your offer is clear or your copy persuasive; that takes a human review.

What's a good website audit score?

Above 80 is solid; above 90 is excellent. But fixing three high-impact problems matters more than chasing the last few points.

Want to know where your own site stands?

A free reading takes about twenty seconds — speed, search, mobile design, security and the path to contact.